(210) 774 6486

Choosing Between Repair and Replace After Water Damaged Contents Recovery

After a flood, leak, or pipe break, one of the hardest decisions a homeowner faces is what to keep and what to let go. While your instinct might be to save everything, some items simply can’t be restored. Others just need the right professional treatment to return to their original condition. Understanding the line between repairable and non-repairable belongings is the key to smart recovery after a disaster. That’s where water damaged contents recovery becomes more than a salvage operation. It becomes a decision-making process.

At Dwyer Restoration, we’ve helped homeowners across Texas sort through soaked furniture, wet documents, electronics, and personal items. Some are easily saved. Others, unfortunately, are too far gone. But we walk alongside our clients to help make those calls clearly, compassionately, and with realistic outcomes. In this blog, we’ll talk about how we evaluate what can be saved, when it makes sense to replace, and how our contents team handles the process from start to finish.

 

Understanding the Type of Water Involved

Not all water damage is equal. Clean water from a supply line or broken pipe is very different from contaminated water from floods or sewage backups. If your contents were exposed to clean water and dried quickly, recovery is often possible. But exposure to Category 2 or 3 water—like that from toilet overflow cleanup, flooded house cleanup, or sewage removal & cleanup—may rule out some items automatically due to health risks.

Our team classifies the type of water first. This determines which contents are candidates for repair and which must be discarded for safety.

 

The Value of the Item

Restoration efforts can involve careful drying, chemical cleaning, ozone deodorizing, and even rebuilding parts of items. These services are valuable, but they come at a cost. It’s important to weigh the replacement cost of an item versus the cost to restore it.

For example, antique furniture might be worth the investment in furniture restoration after flood, while particle-board furniture from a discount store may cost more to repair than replace. Sentimental value also matters. If something is irreplaceable, we will do everything possible to save it.

 

Commonly Recoverable Items

Soft goods like clothing, linens, and drapes can often be saved through soft goods restoration services. Electronics are sometimes recoverable if they weren’t powered on during the incident and are treated promptly through electronics restoration after fire or water exposure. Hard goods like tools, dishes, and sealed containers typically clean up well with minimal effort.

Documents, photos, and paper records may be salvaged using document drying and restoration techniques that stop ink from running and prevent mold growth on pages.

 

What Usually Cannot Be Saved

Items heavily saturated with contaminated water, such as mattresses or certain upholstered furniture, are often beyond repair. Absorbent materials that trap bacteria or break down structurally are better replaced. Similarly, cheap electronics, low-value clothing, or particle board shelving rarely justify the cost of cleaning and drying.

In our contents cleaning and restoration evaluation, we are transparent with homeowners about what can realistically be saved. Our goal is to protect your memories and restore your property, not waste your time or money.

 

Our Step-by-Step Contents Process

Once we assess your items, we begin contents pack out and cleaning to remove salvageable belongings from the home. These items are tagged, inventoried, and taken to our off-site facility for professional restoration. There, we use ultrasonic cleaning, drying chambers, and deodorizing equipment to clean and stabilize them.

While the home undergoes structural restoration or water damage cleanup, your belongings are safe in climate-controlled storage until they are ready to return.

 

When Fire Complicates Water Damage

In many cases, water damage is part of a larger fire damage cleanup or fire damaged contents cleaning scenario. That means items may be exposed to both moisture and smoke. In those situations, contents need a more thorough process that includes smoke damaged item restoration and odor treatment.

Items that seem damaged by water might also need smoke cleanup services or soot and smoke removal to become fully clean and safe again.

 

Items That Require Special Handling

Some belongings, like collectibles, artwork, and heirlooms, fall into a different category. These items require art and collectibles restoration by specialty technicians who understand how to work with delicate surfaces, paint, and materials. We treat these items with white-glove care, recognizing that their value goes far beyond what can be measured in dollars.

Other sensitive categories, like textiles or expensive clothing, may go through textile restoration company partnerships for expert-level results.

 

Odor and Air Treatment for Belongings

Even if an item looks dry, it may still carry a musty or smoky odor. That’s why smoke odor removal and air treatment are part of every pack-out we perform. Items go through ozone or thermal fogging treatments before they are returned.

When needed, we also address smells caused by appliance leak cleanup, clogged drain overflow, or long-standing pipe leak cleanup service jobs where the air was saturated for days or weeks.

 

Making Peace With Letting Go

Some homeowners struggle emotionally with discarding damaged items. That’s completely normal. It’s hard to see beloved belongings lost to a disaster. At Dwyer Restoration, we support families through the process by helping them feel confident and informed about each decision.

Our team explains exactly what can be saved, what can’t, and what to expect at every step of the personal property restoration journey. Whether we are saving a child’s baby book or helping you move forward from unsalvageable furniture, we make the experience as respectful and reassuring as possible.

 

Start With the Right Team

If you’re unsure what to save and what to replace after water damage, the best decision you can make is to start with a team that knows the process inside and out. Dwyer Restoration brings years of experience, professional-grade facilities, and compassionate experts who guide you through one of the hardest parts of the restoration journey.

We handle everything from burst pipe damage cleanup to emergency water removal, and we stand by your side when it comes time to make the tough calls.

Why Choose Dwyer Restoration

100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

Experienced and Specialized in Disaster Restoration

Licensed and Insured

Highly-trained Staff

HAAG Certified Roofer

Our Blogs

Get In Touch

What Our Clients Say

4.8
Based on 108 reviews
powered by Google
S B.
15:38 14 Mar 25
Dwyer Restotation Center as my pick after talking to 4 other companies!
Dan Dwyer is an extremely detailed man and has a goal of doing excellent work in your home. Excellent communication throughout the process and all of his office staff are on the ball! Thank you so much to the Dwyer !
Patricia G
17:39 27 Jan 25
We had quite a bit of damage from a tornado/storm back in May 2024. So we needed a lot of work.
We had used Dwyer Restoration when we lived in Rockport Tx. Which was from Hurricane Harvey in 2017.
He was our Angel.
All the work then and now here in San Marcos TX. The staff and workers have done an outstanding job.
We have another project in the works now.
He is a man of word and will always leave the customer satisfied with the project.
We will continue to use Dwyer Restoration.
Brittany S.
18:23 14 Dec 24
Oh. My. Gosh. I have known about Dwyer for ages, but never in a million years did I think I would need to call a restoration company…until the day came. They were quick, professional, and EXTREMELY knowledgeable. I didn’t question for a second that they knew what they were doing, and they thoroughly answered every question I had along the way. Dwyer, I cannot thank you enough for your help during such a stressful time!
janet B.
20:21 01 Dec 24
Dwyer Restoration is an exemplary company. The staff is knowledgeable, professional and will go above and beyond to complete the job. From top to bottom this company is ready on day one. It was such a pleasure to work with each and every person at this company. I am so grateful for all of them. When disaster strikes this is the only company I want at my side. Bravo Dwyer Restoration Bravo
Julia L.
22:03 28 Oct 24
Great experience working with the Dwyer Team. I would definitely recommend them to others.
Sharon B.
15:11 24 Oct 24
The work project was well done. I was impressed that the owner made site visits even though this was a relatively small project. I appreciated the excellent communication and quality of service. I highly recommend Dwyer Restoration.
David K.
17:40 15 Oct 24
The management representative and all the service personnel were exceptionally communicative and capable.
Gary W.
19:06 04 Oct 24
I had water damage in my master bathroom. Dwyer restoration did a fantastic job fixing the damaged area to where it looks like nothing happened. Very courteous and very professional. Great to work with. I highly recommend them
Jesse S.
00:29 05 Aug 24
Dan and his entire crew were amazing. There were some hiccups along the way (had to change project managers part way through which was out of anyone’s hands). Our new project manager Edward was awesome. The one issue we had was with the subcontractor painting company. Dwyer built us beautiful new cabinets and to this day the paint job is what I would call “satisfactory.” In the end it was quite clear these painters were only going to do enough for a satisfactory job and that is where we left it because we didn’t want to have them come back for a 9th (literally) time. Dan Dwyer and Edward pushed hard to get them to fix things even going as far as to sit here and supervise while they worked. In the end the painters were just lazy and you can’t really fix that. The lesson here is absolutely use Dwyer Restoration. They are prompt, kind, fair, hardworking people and we would use them again in a heartbeat. Their internal survey got an 8/10 overall because of these painters but I do believe deserve a 5 star rating on here because they deserve your business and will not do you wrong. The second lesson is DO NOT use Carnival Painting if you actually want a quality paint job.
Jordan W.
21:35 25 Jul 24
I recently had the pleasure of working with Dwyer Restoration to address significant water damage and mold issues in my home. From start to finish, the experience was exceptional, and I couldn't be more satisfied with their service.

From the moment I contacted them, the team at Dwyer Restoration was responsive and professional. They arrived promptly for the initial assessment, thoroughly inspected the damage, and provided a clear and detailed schedule to address the issues.

The remediation work was carried out efficiently and meticulously. Their team also took great care to protect the unaffected areas of my home. I was particularly impressed with their attention to detail and commitment to quality. My cabinets were needing to be rebuilt, all drywall at the kitchen peninsula was replaced, textured, painted and caulked better than it had been previously when the home was new.

I highly recommend their services. Their professionalism, expertise, and dedication to customer satisfaction make them the best choice for home remediation needs.
Gary D.
15:13 13 Mar 23
We hired Dwyer to do a full kitchen remodel after consulting with a number of local remodel and restoration companies. Their bid was comprehensive and detailed (almost a little overwhelming). They were quick to answer questions and turn the bid back around with adjustments.

The trade workers were competent and always polite. There were a few bumps as I would have expected with any major project. Dwyer responded to each concern in a timely and fair manner. In the end we were very happy with the result and would be willing to use them again.

Some details about the project:
* removed a load-bearing column and replaced with a LVL span. This required adjusting plumbing, electrical and HVAC around the area, as well as working with the city and a structural engineer for approval.
* replaced 4' fluorescent bulb lighting with recessed LEDs.
* custom cabinets (amazing work on this!) and new counters. This included converting the kitchen island into a peninsula.
* rebuild pantry with a slightly different footprint to better utilize space.

The majority of the work was done over about 60 days, with touch-ups and adjustments going on about a month longer.
Kari P.
01:52 18 Aug 20
My neighbor ran his car through my house in December 2019. The entire left side of my house was a huge hole and destroyed. Dwyer Restoration was recommended as the "disaster specialists". I am SO GLAD I hired them out of the 7 others I had come out to give me bids. They were the absolute BEST in the business to work with. I found them to be exceptional in 3 areas specifically:
1. Communication
2. Professionalism
3. Cleanliness
There will always be bumps along the way with ANY restoration/renovation. The key is, to work with people that DO THE RIGHT THING. Dwyer ALWAYS came through no matter what and did the right thing. They handled every detail of my renovation as if it was their house and what they would want done.
Dan Dwyer held my hand throughout the entire insurance process daily and we were able to get things agreed upon due to this.
Mark Brown was my project manager and did a phenomenal job with scheduling and being there every time I called. He was a pleasure to work with and made everything seem so seamless.
Guido Krumm was the German Carpenter that did most of the work on my house. He was also a pleasure to work with. I fell blessed to have had such a knowledgeable and trustworthy person doing the work on my house.
I will ONLY hire Dwyer Restoration in the future for all of my renovation needs. I HIGHLY recommend them for your next project or disaster.
wpChatIcon
    wpChatIcon